Brand collaborations can create buzz, drive sales, and build new audiences, but a poorly executed partnership can damage both brands’ reputations. In this post-mortem, we analyze a brand collaboration gone wrong, drawing actionable insights for business leaders. Read on to discover what happened, where it failed, and how your organization can avoid these critical mistakes.
Understanding Brand Collaboration: The Double-Edged Sword
Brand collaboration is when two or more brands join forces to create a unique product or campaign. This strategy leverages the strengths and audiences of each brand, offering mutual benefits such as market expansion and increased engagement. However, brand collaborations can quickly become risky if values, audiences, or quality standards are misaligned.
According to a Kantar survey in 2025, 42% of successful brand collaborations were rooted in a clear value alignment. Unfortunately, for every synergy, there are examples where poor strategy causes more harm than good, as we’ll see in this post-mortem case.
Case Study: The Collaboration That Damaged Reputations
In early 2025, beverage giant EcoFizz and athletic wear leader RunEdge launched an exclusive “EcoFit Performance Kit.” The kit bundled a limited-edition sports drink with a RunEdge-designed bottle. Announced via a sleek digital campaign, both brands promised sustainability, performance, and innovation—keywords that resonated with their audiences.
Initial excitement was palpable, but consumer trust was quickly undermined. Customers reported that the bottles leaked and the eco-friendly claims did not withstand scrutiny. Soon, social media was flooded with images of the leaking bottles and critiques of “greenwashing.” Within weeks, #EcoFitFail trended across platforms, putting both brands under fire.
Where Did the Collaboration Go Wrong? Lessons Learned
The EcoFizz-RunEdge partnership faltered for several key reasons:
- Insufficient Product Testing: Rushing the limited-edition bottle to market without thorough testing resulted in widespread leaks and dissatisfied customers.
- Misaligned Brand Values: Both brands boasted sustainability, but third-party reviews exposed discrepancies in supply chain practices, casting doubt on environmental claims.
- Poor Crisis Management: Instead of addressing concerns with transparency, both brands initially issued generic apologies, which customers perceived as evasive.
- Failure to Understand Audiences: The collaboration overlooked that RunEdge’s audience valued durability, while EcoFizz’s cared about environmental credentials. The product failed to deliver on both counts.
This multi-layered breakdown demonstrates why brand collaborations demand more than slick marketing. Functional excellence, authentic storytelling, and open communication are critical to building—and maintaining—trust.
The Reputational Fallout: How Both Brands Suffered
The negative publicity from the EcoFit Performance Kit collaboration was swift and damaging. Social listening analytics from April 2025 showed sentiment around both brands dropped by 28% in just two weeks. EcoFizz’s stock price declined 10% following the controversy, and RunEdge saw a drop in customer retention rates.
Trust erosion wasn’t confined to the product itself. Customers questioned other sustainability claims, causing ongoing reputational damage. Influencers and journalists called out what they described as “performative partnership,” adding to the backlash. In today’s digital ecosystem, one flawed product can echo across an entire brand’s reputation—and beyond.
Recovering From a Failed Brand Collaboration
Recovery from a reputational hit like this requires swift, strategic action. Both EcoFizz and RunEdge ultimately implemented these steps:
- Ownership and Transparency: After initial missteps, both brands published detailed explanations, outlined corrective actions, and established recall programs for faulty bottles.
- Stakeholder Engagement: Each company held joint and separate Q&A webinars for customers, giving loyal fans a voice in the future of their eco initiatives.
- Independent Audits: To restore credibility, third-party auditors assessed the environmental claims and manufacturing processes, sharing findings publicly.
- Rebuilding Trust: Both brands made significant charity donations and partnered with authentic sustainability consultants, signaling long-term commitment to their values.
This proactive approach helped stabilize customer sentiment, although full reputation recovery took months. The experience forced each brand to reevaluate future collaboration criteria—a lesson no contemporary business can afford to ignore.
How to Avoid Damaging Brand Partnerships in the Future
Learning from the EcoFizz-RunEdge example, organizations aiming for successful brand collaborations should adhere to the following advice:
- Thorough Due Diligence: Ensure product quality with rigorous tests before launch. Cross-check supply chain claims and audit environmental impacts.
- Align on Values and Audiences: Confirm both brands’ values match—and that an overlap in target audiences makes practical sense.
- Craft Clear Communication: Set expectations with customers honestly and transparently. Address any issues promptly and with full disclosure.
- Plan Crisis Protocols: Prepare a response plan for potential failures. Practice honest engagement instead of “damage control” messaging.
- Focus on Long-Term Relationships: Prioritize reputation over short-term hype. Build trust and collaboration frameworks that extend beyond a single campaign.
By prioritizing these fundamentals, brands can create meaningful partnerships and minimize risk, even in highly public collaborations.
FAQs: Brand Collaboration and Reputation Management
-
What is a brand collaboration?
A brand collaboration is a joint partnership between two or more brands to create a unique offering, leveraging each other’s strengths, audiences, and market presence for mutual benefit. -
How can a brand collaboration go wrong?
Problems arise from misaligned values, poor product quality, inadequate communication, or failure to manage customer expectations. A misstep can quickly escalate, damaging both brands’ reputations and customer trust. -
What should brands do after a failed collaboration?
Brands should act quickly by admitting mistakes, implementing recalls or fixes, communicating transparently, and conducting independent audits. Engaging customers directly and outlining changes can help restore trust. -
How can businesses prevent reputational damage from partnerships?
Preventative steps include thorough vetting of partners, quality assurance testing, shared values verification, crisis management preparation, and honest customer communication from the outset. -
Are brand collaborations still effective in 2025?
Yes, when planned and executed carefully, brand collaborations remain a powerful tool in 2025 for expanding market reach and driving innovation—but only when authenticity, quality, and trust are at the forefront.
When pursuing brand collaborations, the key is authenticity, preparation, and clear communication. As the EcoFizz-RunEdge story shows, aligning brand values and prioritizing quality protects reputation. Sustainable, successful partnerships are built on trust—never on shortcuts or marketing hype.